Update 306: Economic Generational Justice Salient Issues for Millennials in the Midterms
The generation of millennials, Americans born between 1983 and 2000, consists of 80 million people and accounts for 25 percent of the population, 35 percent of the workforce. Millennials receive lower relative wages, take on more debt, face higher housing costs, and pay expensive college tuition, with Trump administration policy aggravating a condition many call a generational injustice.
Millennials’ economic plight affects how they vote, and it is becoming increasingly important to advocate for policies that address these generational imbalances. Many Democratic candidates are campaigning with progressive social and economic messages that resonate with younger voters — but will millennials turn out en masse at the ballot box next month?
Highly Educated, but Perennially in Debt
Millennials are the most educated generation to date. Women age 18 to 33 today are particularly better educated, with 27 percent attaining a bachelor’s degree or higher in 2014, compared to just 14 percent in 1980. This educational attainment comes at a price. Adjusted for inflation, the average cost of an undergraduate degree has risen over 160 percent from 1987 to 2016.
The increased cost of college has led to an increase in borrowing. The average debt burden of a recent graduate is over $37,000 — $20,000 more than it was over a decade ago. The average monthly student loan payment has skyrocketed over 70 percent, from $227 in 2005 to $393 in 2016. Rapidly rising tuition and burgeoning debt have stymied millennials’ full participation in the broader economy.
Underpaid and Underemployed
Millennials may be the largest generation in the workforce to date, but they are underpaid and underemployed compared to their Baby Boomer counterparts a generation earlier. A 2017 Young Invincible’s report found that millennials’ net worth is about half that of the Boomers’ net worth at the same age. Young workers’ wages have also fallen 20 percent since the Boomer era.
Those born in 1950 had a 79 percent chance of out-earning their parents; that chance has slipped to 50 percent for people born after 1980. Although educational attainment is still the best route to financial security, the report concludes that a market flooded with four-year-degree holders has caused employers to raise hiring standards, even for entry-level positions.
Millennial unemployment is double the national average — about seven percent, while the national average is 3.7 — with 11 percent for African American and 7.5 percent for Latin millennials in 2017. Though millennial unemployment is a serious issue, millennial underemployment — involuntarily working part time or being overqualified for a position — is widespread, severe, and, for the most part, not talked about.
In 2013, 41 percent of millennials between the ages of 22 and 27 reported underemployment, with the number rising to 51 percent in 2016. As millennials continue to pursue degrees and low-paying, entry-level jobs require more and more experience, this problem will only get worse.
The Rent is Too Damn High
Millennials are categorically less likely to own a house, preferring instead to rent. A recent report by the Urban Institute showed the millennial homeownership rate at 37 percent in 2015, approximately 8 points lower than that of Gen Xers and Baby Boomers at the same age. There are three main economic factors that contribute to this trend:
- High rent costs: Nearly half the people polled spent more than 30% of their income on rent, classifying them as rent-burdened. Those classified rent-burdened are more likely to be in financially precarious situations and less likely to be able to buy a home.
- Student loan debt: Student debt delays millennial homeownership for seven years. Many millennials, even older members of the generation, do not feel financially secure enough to buy homes because they are unable to save.
- The Great Recession: Memories of the 2008 financial crisis, during which time many millennials entered the workforce or tried to, have had pervasive effects on their ability to achieve financially stability — one Morgan Stanley analyst told Business Insider that the financial crisis left an entire generation with a “significant psychological scar.”
Larger Premiums, Worse Coverage
Although initiatives under the ACA, such as staying on parents’ plans until 26, have reduced the total of uninsured millennials, 16 percent of young adults still went uninsured in 2016. Millennials make up nearly half of all uninsured people in the U.S. A 2016 poll found that 20 percent of adults aged 18-36 cannot afford routine healthcare expenses, with 26 percent saying that they can, but with difficulty. The most cited reason for delaying treatment was a lack of affordability. Even monthly premiums as low as $200 pose a financial hurdle for many millennials whose budgets are already constrained by mandatory student loan payments and high housing costs.
Not Entitled to Entitlements?
By 2022, Social Security will be paying more out in benefits than it is gaining from revenue, and it is predicted that by 2034, all of its asset reserves will be exhausted. Generally, the way to increase funding for programs is to increase tax revenues and/or lower the federal debt. Instead, Congress passed a tax bill that will add $1.5 trillion to the federal debt and reduce tax revenue.
The recent tax cuts were a large transfer payment to older, wealthier Americans. Providing immediate relief for taxpayers now and over the course of the next ten years amounts to fiscal theft from the younger generation. The added debt and the resulting higher interest payments come at an opportunity cost to investment in entitlements and programs that would otherwise have benefited the millennial generation.
51 percent of millennials don’t expect to receive anything from the program when they retire. Per Bloomberg, “any solution that would rectify [Social Security’s] finances will probably require more taxes and more benefit cuts—all coming out of the pockets of younger workers.” As things stand, millennials will face a large federal debt burden and will either get less Social Security benefits than their parents, or will have to retire much later than previous generations.
Through the Midterm Lens
For Democrats to win the House this cycle, millennials are going to have to show up as a greater percentage of the vote than they did in the last midterm election. In 2014, 22 percent of voting-age millennials voted, accounting for 16 percent of the vote — a historic low. The Cook Political Report describes millennials as “volatile” in terms of turnout and, along with Latinx voters, the likeliest to drop out of the electorate. Democrats are trying to advocate for issues that matter to millennials, such as reducing the cost of higher education, entitlement security, and healthcare, in an effort to turn them out. Many 2018 Democratic House candidates are putting these issues at the forefront of their campaigns.
These efforts appear to be working. An NBC poll from August found that 55 percent of millennials say they will probably or definitely vote in this year’s midterm election. Republicans haven’t exactly helped their cause with millennials, enacting regressive tax cuts that will harm future generations and attempting to bring down a healthcare system that benefits young workers. Democrats are hoping that by appealing to these young people, they will be able ride the millennial voter wave come November.
Other Related Articles
- Update 715 — Weekly Economic Roundup
- Proposed Designation of Nonbank Financial Company for Supervision by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
- Update 710 — Econ. Policy Week in Review:Legislative Push in Run-up to August Recess
- Update 709 — Summer of Labor Discontent: What’s at Stake for Workers in the Strikes?
- Fed Rates, Crypto on Front Burner